Encryption 12 May 2021

Internet Society: UK Online Public Safety Bill is trying to legislate the impossible – a safe Internet without strong encryption

In the Queen’s Speech on 11 May 2021, the UK Government said it wants to “harness the benefits of a free, open and secure Internet”. It also asserted its commitment to online safety for all, especially for children. These are valid goals, but they cannot be achieved without strong, reliable encryption.

With its draft Online Public Safety Bill, the UK government is trying to legislate the impossible – a safe Internet without strong encryption – in the face of clear and consistent technical analysis saying that it cannot be done [1],[2].

Encryption technology keeps you safe: it secures your transactions, preserves your confidentiality, and in a world of connected objects, it protects your physical safety. Weakening, bypassing or removing encryption puts everyone, including children, at greater risk: it exposes their communications to third parties, and it deprives children of secure lifelines to help and advice.

Anyone advocating for encryption to be bypassed, removed, or omitted must show that doing so would not create points of access that put children and adults at risk of fraud, exploitation, and physical harm. This is simply not possible: there are no “safe back doors” to encrypted communication, and those calling for them cannot stop them from being discovered and misused.

The most effective way to protect the safety and security of citizens – of every age – is through uncompromised, end-to-end encryption services, supported by strong encryption policies.

[1] Breaking Encryption Myths: https://www.globalencryption.org/2020/11/breaking-encryption-myths/
[2] Keys under Doormats: https://dspace.mit.edu/handle/1721.1/97690

Related resources

Strengthening the Internet 4 February 2022

Internet Society Statement on EARN IT Act 2022

The Internet Society calls on senators to protect strong encryption by opposing the re-introduced EARN IT Act.

Encryption 1 March 2021

Internet Society Statement regarding the Indian Information Technology (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics Code) Rules 2021

The new requirements in the the Indian Information Technology (Guidelines for Intermediaries and Digital Media Ethics Code) Rules, 2021...

Internet Way of Networking 23 September 2020

Internet Society: Russia’s Proposal Would Weaken the Internet, Make It Less Secure

Media reports that proposed Russian legislation would ban certain kinds of encrypted Internet connections are part of a worrying...