Donate
US Senate Makes Moves to Reinstate Net Neutrality, But Sustainable Rules Are Still Necessary Thumbnail
‹ Back
Connecting the World 22 May 2018

US Senate Makes Moves to Reinstate Net Neutrality, But Sustainable Rules Are Still Necessary

Katie Jordan
By Katie JordanSenior Policy Advisor, North America

On May 16, the Senate passed a Congressional Review Act (CRA) to overturn the Federal Communication Commission’s (FCC) repeal of the 2015 Open Internet Order. A CRA allows Congress to review regulations issued by government agencies and overrule them with a majority vote. This vote, led by Senator Ed Markey (D-MA), is a step towards reinstating the FCC’s 2015 net neutrality rules.

The CRA will now move to the House, where it will require a majority vote in order to pass before heading to President Trump’s desk for his signature. If the CRA passes the House and gets the President’s signature, the 2015 Order will be reinstated.

Despite the CRA’s success in the Senate, it is unlikely that it will pass the House. In the Senate, every Democrat, two Independents, and three Republicans were needed to pass the CRA. In the House, Democrats hold just 193 of 435 seats and would need to be joined by 25 Republican or Independent Representatives to move the CRA to the President’s desk. Even then, the bill would face another major hurdle, as President Trump has previously expressed support for overturning the FCC’s Open Internet Order.

This is not to mention the court cases currently filed against the FCC over its repeal of the Open Internet Order. If the CRA fails to pass, these cases will continue for many months, with no clear timeline or outcome. If the CRA does pass, the cases will drop, but new ones are likely to be filed arguing against the reinstatement of the Order.

The motion still has a long way to go. The legal battle for net neutrality has already lasted years and could be drawn out for several more before sustainable, concrete rules are put in place. This will only increase confusion among end users and service providers. It is time to come up with a long-lasting compromise that prioritizes the needs of end-users and ensures a policy environment that encourages investment and innovation.

While we applaud Congress’ effort to ensure that the Internet remain open and accessible, we encourage all stakeholders to come together to propose a sustainable solution. Congressional representatives, government agencies, service providers, edge-providers, and public interest groups must work together to create and implement a solution and end the state of back-and-forth policy-making that has existed for too long.

‹ Back

Disclaimer: Viewpoints expressed in this post are those of the author and may or may not reflect official Internet Society positions.

Related articles

New Developments in the Net Neutrality Debate
New Developments in the Net Neutrality Debate
Public Policy12 January 2018

New Developments in the Net Neutrality Debate

Democrats in the USA haven’t given up on net neutrality since the FCC voted to repeal the 2015 Open Internet Order in December. Senator Markey, a Democrat from Massachusetts, has put forward a bill that would use the Congressional Review Act (CRA) to reverse the Federal Communications Commission’s (FCC) decision. The CRA allows lawmakers 60 legislative days after the FCC submits its regulations to Congress to take action.

The Week in Internet News: Tech Giants’ ‘Ethical AI' Efforts Scrutinized
The Week in Internet News: Tech Giants’ ‘Ethical AI' Efforts Scrutinized
Technology15 April 2019

The Week in Internet News: Tech Giants’ ‘Ethical AI’ Efforts Scrutinized

Building nice AIs: Efforts by large tech vendors to think about ways to design “ethical Artificial Intelligence" systems have hit...

Nouveaux développements dans le débat sur la neutralité du Net
Nouveaux développements dans le débat sur la neutralité du Net
Connecting the World12 January 2018

Nouveaux développements dans le débat sur la neutralité du Net

Les démocrates aux États-Unis n'ont pas renoncé à la neutralité du net depuis la FCC a voté pour l'abrogation 2015 de l'ordre Internet ouvert en Décembre. Le sénateur Markey, un démocrate du Massachusetts, a présenté un projet de loi qui utiliserait la Loi sur le contrôle du Congrès (CRA) pour renverser la décision de la Federal Communications Commission (FCC). L'ARC permet aux législateurs 60 jours législatifs après que la FCC soumette ses règlements au Congrès d'agir.

Join the conversation with Internet Society members around the world